Conectar

AMJ Review Process Guide

brycewang-stanfordbybrycewang-stanford
•
1.1k
•
Aprendizaje y Documentación

Guides authors through interpreting Academy of Management Journal (AMJ) decision letters and navigating the multi-round developmental review process.

The AMJ Review Process skill helps academic researchers understand and navigate the editorial standards, multi-round R&R culture, and peer-review norms of the Academy of Management Journal. It provides structured guidance on interpreting decision letters, prioritizing action editor feedback over simple reviewer vote counts, categorizing critique points across theory and methodology, and distinguishing fatal flaws from addressable revisions before formulating a formal rebuttal strategy.

Características Principales

01Extracts and ranks action editor priorities over conflicting reviewer comments
021,069 GitHub stars
03Interprets AMJ editorial decision letters across R&R, reject-and-resubmit, and reject outcomes
04Provides structured review diagnostic outputs to prepare for revision planning
05Categorizes reviewer feedback into theory, method, analysis, framing, and writing dimensions
06Evaluates the feasibility of required empirical analyses and theoretical expansions

Casos de Uso

01Pre-submission calibration to understand AMJ desk-review criteria and review turnaround expectations
02Mapping reviewer demands and identifying conflicting feedback before drafting a formal rebuttal
03Decoding an incoming AMJ decision letter to assess developmental viability and next steps