Annual Review of Economics Revision Assistant

•
1.1k
•

Guides authors through responding to Editorial Committee and referee feedback on Annual Review of Economics survey articles.

The arecon-revision skill assists economics researchers in managing the revision process for Annual Review of Economics (ARE) manuscripts. It systematically triages referee and editorial feedback into actionable categories—such as coverage omissions, balance complaints, framework adjustments, and accessibility critiques—and generates structured revision ledgers and point-by-point response letters. By helping authors integrate missing literatures, steelman competing perspectives, and refine theoretical spines within strict volume page constraints, this skill ensures invited review papers meet the publication standards of top-tier economics journals.

Características Principales

01Economics revision ledger generation linking additions to theoretical, empirical, or welfare insights
02Page budget and volume deadline management to keep revisions within editorial constraints
03Point-by-point response letter drafting with exact text locations and quote-response formatting
041,069 GitHub stars
05Feedback triaging into coverage, balance, appraisal accuracy, framework, accessibility, and scope
06Steelmanning and balance auditing to resolve referee conflicts and self-citation concerns

Casos de Uso

01Responding to Annual Review of Economics referee reports and Editorial Committee decision letters
02Integrating omitted economics literature into existing review frameworks without bloating scope
03Converting 'annotated bibliography' critiques into cohesive, theory-grounded review spines