Does this skill replace manual code reviews?

It acts as a senior-level 'first pass' or co-pilot, catching complex bugs and architectural issues to make human reviews faster and more focused on high-level strategy.

What specific code qualities does the consultant check?

It evaluates 10 key categories including correctness, type safety, observability, fault semantics, design clarity, modularity, and test quality.

How does the Review skill prioritize findings?

It uses five distinct severity levels—Blocker, High, Medium, Low, and Info—to help developers focus on critical logic bugs and data corruption risks first.

Can it handle large pull requests?

Yes, the skill features depth scaling that applies the full 10-category framework to changes over 300 lines while focusing on core correctness for smaller diffs.

What is the primary philosophy of this review tool?

The core principle is 'Correctness Above All,' prioritizing working code and system stability over purely aesthetic or stylistic code changes.

Consultant Code Review

Name: Consultant Code Review
Author: doodledood

bydoodledood

•

Herramientas de Colaboración

Performs rigorous, production-grade code reviews using a specialized 10-category framework focused on logic, correctness, and maintainability.

Acerca de

The Review skill equips Claude with a consultant-level framework for performing deep-dive architectural and logic audits on pull requests. By leveraging a structured 10-point inspection system—covering everything from type safety and fault semantics to observability and data evolution—it identifies critical blockers and subtle bugs before they reach production. The skill intelligently scales its analysis depth based on the size of the code change, ensuring that large-scale refactors receive a comprehensive framework review while small changes remain focused on core logic and correctness.

Características Principales

Dynamic depth scaling that adjusts review intensity based on pull request size.
Specialized consultant subagent integration for high-confidence architectural reasoning.
Structured 10-category framework covering logic, type safety, and fault containment.
Standardized severity levels from 'Blocker' to 'Info' for prioritized remediation.
8 GitHub stars
Automated 'Top 5 Action Items' summary for immediate high-impact fixes.

Casos de Uso

Pre-production audits to identify silent logic bugs and data corruption risks.
Reviewing large-scale refactors where regression testing and fault semantics are critical.
Automated quality gates for ensuring type safety and architectural consistency across teams.

Acerca de

Características Principales

Dynamic depth scaling that adjusts review intensity based on pull request size.
Specialized consultant subagent integration for high-confidence architectural reasoning.
Structured 10-category framework covering logic, type safety, and fault containment.
Standardized severity levels from 'Blocker' to 'Info' for prioritized remediation.
8 GitHub stars
Automated 'Top 5 Action Items' summary for immediate high-impact fixes.

Casos de Uso

Pre-production audits to identify silent logic bugs and data corruption risks.
Reviewing large-scale refactors where regression testing and fault semantics are critical.
Automated quality gates for ensuring type safety and architectural consistency across teams.