Content Quality Rubric
Evaluates finished content against ten scoring dimensions to ensure publishable standards and automate rework routing.
The Quality Rubric skill provides a rigorous, evidence-based evaluation gate for the Madman-Architect-Carpenter-Judge writing framework. It scores content on a 1-5 scale across ten critical dimensions—including thesis strength, structural flow, and technical accuracy—to ensure every piece meets high-quality publishing standards. By mapping low scores back to specific workflow phases (such as returning structural issues to the Architect), it prevents the common mistake of trying to fix fundamental content flaws with surface-level editing. This skill acts as a final gatekeeper, providing objective scorecards and actionable rework directives before publication.