Conectar

Marketing Science R&R Rebuttal Letter Drafter

brycewang-stanfordbybrycewang-stanford
•
1.1k
•
Aprendizaje y Documentación

Drafts point-by-point revise-and-resubmit response letters for Marketing Science manuscripts addressing econometric identification, counterfactuals, and reviewer feedback.

The mksc-rebuttal skill guides academic researchers through drafting comprehensive, point-by-point response and rebuttal letters for revise-and-resubmit (R&R) decisions at Marketing Science. It structures structured responses to Senior/Associate Editors and reviewers across multiple rounds, providing proven response strategies for rigorous domain-specific critiques like identification strategies, model assumptions, counterfactual validity, computation, and replication package updates. It also helps navigate conflicting reviewer suggestions and ensures compliance with ScholarOne blind review constraints and Frontiers article word limits.

Características Principales

01Structures point-by-point rebuttal letters for Associate Editors and reviewers
02Manages manuscript word-count and online appendix distribution for Frontiers formats
031,086 GitHub stars
04Provides targeted response strategies for econometric identification and modeling objections
05Ensures compliance with replication package updates and code verification
06Guides reconciliation of conflicting reviewer demands transparently for the AE

Casos de Uso

01Formulating rigorous evidence-based rebuttals to identification and model assumption critiques
02Reconciling contradictory reviewer requests and presenting justified trade-offs to the handling AE
03Drafting an R&R response letter after updating econometric models and counterfactual analyses