接続

CAR Peer Review Guide

brycewang-stanfordbybrycewang-stanford
•
1.1k
•
学習とドキュメンテーション

Navigates the Contemporary Accounting Research (CAR) peer review process, decodes editorial decision letters, and explains journal-specific policies.

Designed for academic accounting researchers submitting to Contemporary Accounting Research (CAR), this skill provides specialized guidance on navigating the journal's double-anonymous peer review system. It helps authors interpret nuanced feedback in decision letters, map editorial hierarchies between Subject Editors and the Editor-in-Chief, and understand critical journal policies regarding reviewer GenAI restrictions, desk-reject fee refunds, and formal appeal procedures.

主な機能

01Outlines desk-reject fee refund terms and acceptance criteria
02Decodes Subject Editor decision letters to pinpoint first-order revision priorities
03Provides guidelines, timelines, and requirements for filing formal manuscript appeals
04Clarifies editorial roles between handling Subject Editors and the Editor-in-Chief
05Explains double-anonymous peer review rules and reviewer GenAI restrictions
061,074 GitHub stars

ユースケース

01Calibrating submission expectations and workflow steps before submitting a manuscript to CAR
02Assessing the viability and procedural requirements of submitting a formal appeal after a rejection
03Interpreting a CAR decision letter to distinguish central editorial directives from secondary reviewer feedback