When will this skill push back against a suggestion?

It triggers pushback if a suggestion violates YAGNI principles, breaks existing functionality, lacks context, or conflicts with established architectural decisions.

Does this skill work with GitHub pull requests?

Yes, it includes specific guidance for replying within GitHub comment threads to ensure communication stays organized and context-aware.

How does it handle external reviewer feedback?

The skill treats external feedback with healthy skepticism, requiring a 5-point check for technical correctness, context, and potential regressions before implementation.

Why does this skill discourage saying 'thank you' in reviews?

It prioritizes 'actions over words,' replacing performative gratitude with technical verification and immediate implementation to maintain a high-signal communication style.

What happens if a review contains unclear instructions?

The skill mandates a full stop on implementation. It will ask for clarification on all items before proceeding to avoid partial or incorrect changes.

Code Review Reception

Name: Code Review Reception
Author: ben-mad-jlp

byben-mad-jlp

コラボレーションツール

Standardizes the reception of code review feedback by prioritizing technical rigor and verification over performative agreement.

概要

The Code Review Reception skill provides a structured framework for Claude to process and implement technical feedback with high integrity. Instead of providing empty acknowledgments, this skill enforces a 'verify-before-implement' workflow that checks suggestions against the actual codebase, identifies YAGNI violations, and ensures all requirements are fully understood before execution. It includes specific protocols for handling external reviewers, managing unclear instructions, and pushing back against technically unsound suggestions using objective reasoning.

主な機能

Structured response patterns for technical acknowledgment and clarification
0 GitHub stars
Prioritized implementation order for multi-item feedback blocks
YAGNI (You Ain't Gonna Need It) checks for unnecessary feature requests
Verification protocols to check suggestions against current codebase reality
Source-specific handling for human partners versus external reviewers

ユースケース

Evaluating and responding to external security or performance audits
Processing complex pull request feedback while maintaining architectural integrity
Clarifying ambiguous or conflicting technical instructions from multiple stakeholders

概要

主な機能

Structured response patterns for technical acknowledgment and clarification
0 GitHub stars
Prioritized implementation order for multi-item feedback blocks
YAGNI (You Ain't Gonna Need It) checks for unnecessary feature requests
Verification protocols to check suggestions against current codebase reality
Source-specific handling for human partners versus external reviewers

ユースケース

Evaluating and responding to external security or performance audits
Processing complex pull request feedback while maintaining architectural integrity
Clarifying ambiguous or conflicting technical instructions from multiple stakeholders