Why does this skill discourage saying 'thank you'?

It follows a philosophy where technical actions and correctness are prioritized over social performance, keeping the developer conversation focused, efficient, and professional.

How does this skill change Claude's response to feedback?

It prevents Claude from using performative phrases like 'You're right!' or 'Thanks!' and instead focuses on restating requirements and verifying changes against the actual codebase.

Can Claude push back on my feedback with this skill enabled?

Yes. If a suggestion is technically incorrect, breaks existing functionality, or violates YAGNI principles, Claude will provide a reasoned technical pushback rather than blindly implementing it.

What happens if the code review feedback is unclear?

Claude will stop implementation and ask for clarification on specific items before proceeding, ensuring that partial understanding doesn't lead to wrong implementations.

Code Review Reception

Name: Code Review Reception
Author: carlopezzuto

bycarlopezzuto

0•

コラボレーションツール

Implements a rigorous, verification-first approach to processing code review feedback by prioritizing technical correctness over performative agreement.

The receiving-code-review skill transforms how Claude interacts with developer feedback by enforcing a strict protocol of technical verification. It prevents 'blind implementation' of suggestions and eliminates polite but unproductive filler phrases, focusing instead on clarifying requirements, checking against codebase reality, and applying YAGNI principles. This skill is particularly valuable for maintaining architectural integrity when dealing with multiple reviewers, ensuring that Claude only implements changes that are technically sound and necessary for the current project scope.

主な機能

01Structured clarification process for ambiguous feedback

020 GitHub stars

03Elimination of performative and polite filler responses

04Verification-first implementation protocol

05Automated YAGNI (You Aren't Gonna Need It) checks

06Context-aware pushback against technically incorrect suggestions

ユースケース

01Processing complex feedback from multiple human reviewers

02Filtering out unnecessary feature requests to avoid scope creep

03Maintaining technical consistency and architectural integrity during iterations

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add carlopezzuto/agents receiving-code-review

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT

Download Skill