Does this skill work with external code reviewers?

Yes, it includes a specific 'Skeptical Verification' workflow for external feedback to ensure suggestions align with the project's specific context and constraints.

Can Claude push back on my feedback with this skill?

Yes, if a suggestion is technically incorrect, breaks existing functionality, or violates YAGNI principles, Claude will provide a reasoned technical pushback.

How does it handle GitHub reviews?

It ensures replies are made within the specific inline comment threads using the GitHub API rather than as top-level PR comments.

Why does this skill discourage saying 'You're right'?

To prioritize technical verification over performative agreement, ensuring changes are made based on code reality rather than social comfort.

How does the skill handle unclear feedback?

It mandates stopping and asking for clarification on all items before implementing any part of the request to prevent partial or incorrect implementations.

Code Review Reception

Name: Code Review Reception
Author: flosrn

byflosrn

0•

コラボレーションツール

Standardizes how Claude processes and implements code review feedback with technical rigor and objective verification.

This skill provides a structured framework for Claude to handle code review feedback by prioritizing technical correctness over social agreement. It mandates a verify-before-implementing approach, ensures Claude avoids performative phrases like 'You're absolutely right,' and provides clear protocols for handling unclear suggestions or pushing back on suboptimal feedback. By focusing on technical acknowledgment and systematic implementation, it helps maintain codebase integrity and avoids unnecessary feature bloat during the collaborative development process.

主な機能

01Intelligent pushback logic for technically questionable feedback

02Automated GitHub thread reply handling for inline comments

03Technical verification protocol for all review suggestions

040 GitHub stars

05Structured multi-item implementation and testing workflow

06Elimination of performative or overly agreeable social responses

ユースケース

01Responding to human partner feedback on a Pull Request

02Evaluating and filtering suggestions from external automated or human reviewers

03Identifying and rejecting unnecessary feature bloat (YAGNI) during review

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add flosrn/.claude receiving-code-review

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT

主な機能

01Intelligent pushback logic for technically questionable feedback

02Automated GitHub thread reply handling for inline comments

03Technical verification protocol for all review suggestions

040 GitHub stars

05Structured multi-item implementation and testing workflow

06Elimination of performative or overly agreeable social responses

ユースケース

01Responding to human partner feedback on a Pull Request

02Evaluating and filtering suggestions from external automated or human reviewers

03Identifying and rejecting unnecessary feature bloat (YAGNI) during review

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add flosrn/.claude receiving-code-review

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT