How does the skill handle unclear feedback?

It implements a stop-and-ask protocol, preventing partial or incorrect implementations by requiring clarification on all items before proceeding with any changes.

How does this improve the developer experience?

It results in higher quality code changes and more honest technical communication, reducing the risk of bugs introduced by blind compliance to reviewer suggestions.

What is the 'YAGNI' check feature?

It prompts Claude to search the codebase for actual usage before implementing 'proper' features suggested by reviewers, avoiding unnecessary code bloat and maintenance overhead.

Why does this skill forbid saying 'Thanks' or 'Great point'?

It prevents 'performative agreement,' ensuring Claude focuses on technical correctness and actual implementation rather than social pleasantries that can mask technical errors.

When will Claude push back on a reviewer's suggestion?

Claude will push back if a suggestion violates technical constraints, breaks existing functionality, lacks context, or conflicts with established architectural decisions.

Code Review Reception Specialist

Name: Code Review Reception Specialist
Author: Kingly-Agency

byKingly-Agency

コラボレーションツール

Optimizes code review workflows by enforcing technical verification and eliminating performative agreement in response to feedback.

概要

This skill transforms how Claude interacts with code review feedback, shifting the focus from social compliance to technical accuracy. It establishes a rigorous response pattern that prioritizes codebase reality over blind implementation, requiring Claude to verify suggestions, ask for clarification on ambiguous items, and provide reasoned technical pushback when necessary. By forbidding performative gratitude and focusing on action and evidence, it ensures that only technically sound, necessary changes are merged into your project.

主な機能

Verification-first workflow for all feedback items
Strict elimination of performative language and empty gratitude
Automated YAGNI checks for redundant feature suggestions
Structured handling for multi-item feedback and ambiguous instructions
Technical pushback logic based on stack compatibility and legacy constraints
0 GitHub stars

ユースケース

Processing large batches of feedback from multiple stakeholders without losing context
Managing technical disagreements between external reviewers and internal project standards
Filtering out unnecessary features suggested by reviewers that aren't used in the codebase

概要

主な機能

Verification-first workflow for all feedback items
Strict elimination of performative language and empty gratitude
Automated YAGNI checks for redundant feature suggestions
Structured handling for multi-item feedback and ambiguous instructions
Technical pushback logic based on stack compatibility and legacy constraints
0 GitHub stars

ユースケース

Processing large batches of feedback from multiple stakeholders without losing context
Managing technical disagreements between external reviewers and internal project standards
Filtering out unnecessary features suggested by reviewers that aren't used in the codebase