Why does this skill prohibit saying 'Thanks' or 'Great point'?

The skill prioritizes technical action over social performance. It follows the principle that fixed code and technical acknowledgment are the best ways to respect a reviewer's time.

Does it always follow reviewer suggestions?

No. It encourages technical pushback if a suggestion violates YAGNI principles, breaks existing functionality, or contradicts prior architectural decisions made by the lead developer.

How does it handle unclear feedback?

If any part of a review is unclear, the skill instructs Claude to stop and ask for clarification on all items before implementing any changes, preventing partial or wrong implementations.

What is the YAGNI check feature?

Before implementing 'proper' features suggested by reviewers, the skill greps the codebase for actual usage to ensure the project doesn't add complexity for unused endpoints or features.

Code Review Reception & Technical Rigor

Name: Code Review Reception & Technical Rigor
Author: tianyuanztm

bytianyuanztm

0•

コラボレーションツール

Implements a technically rigorous framework for processing code review feedback without performative agreement or blind implementation.

The Code Review Reception skill equips Claude with a structured protocol for handling code review suggestions, prioritizing technical correctness over social politeness. It establishes a 'Verify before Implementing' workflow that requires restating requirements, checking suggestions against the actual codebase reality, and providing reasoned technical pushback when necessary. By eliminating performative phrases and focusing on actionable fixes and YAGNI (You Aren't Gonna Need It) checks, it ensures that only necessary, verified, and high-quality changes are integrated into your project.

主な機能

01YAGNI validation to filter out unnecessary or unused feature suggestions

02Technical pushback guidelines based on codebase context and architecture

03Standardized GitHub thread reply management for organized communication

04Verification-first workflow to prevent blind or incorrect implementation

050 GitHub stars

06Structured multi-item feedback handling to ensure total clarity before coding

ユースケース

01Processing complex feedback from external open-source contributors with skepticism

02Managing rapid-fire review comments from a lead developer with technical precision

03Evaluating and implementing multi-part refactoring requests without breaking legacy support

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add tianyuanztm/myplan receiving-code-review

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT

主な機能

01YAGNI validation to filter out unnecessary or unused feature suggestions

02Technical pushback guidelines based on codebase context and architecture

03Standardized GitHub thread reply management for organized communication

04Verification-first workflow to prevent blind or incorrect implementation

050 GitHub stars

06Structured multi-item feedback handling to ensure total clarity before coding

ユースケース

01Processing complex feedback from external open-source contributors with skepticism

02Managing rapid-fire review comments from a lead developer with technical precision

03Evaluating and implementing multi-part refactoring requests without breaking legacy support