Does the Moderator control the experts' responses?

No. After providing the initial briefing and research context, the Moderator allows experts to communicate directly with one another. The Moderator only intervenes if the discussion stalls or goes off-topic.

When should I use the Arena skill instead of a standard Claude query?

Use Arena for complex, multi-faceted questions where there isn't a single 'correct' answer, such as architectural choices or strategic planning. It is designed for depth and debate rather than quick factual answers.

What kind of output does the Arena skill provide?

The final output is a detailed Synthesis Document saved to your repository. It includes a trust summary, a catalog of de-duplicated evidence, and a clear breakdown of where experts agreed or disagreed.

How many experts are involved in a typical debate?

The skill typically recruits between 3 to 5 distinct expert personas to ensure a diverse range of perspectives, including at least one designated Devil's Advocate.

Can Arena be used for non-coding questions?

Yes. While it excels at technical architecture, the Arena skill is domain-agnostic and can orchestrate debates on business strategy, philosophy, science, or any field with established expert personas.

Expert Arena Moderator

Name: Expert Arena Moderator
Author: izzzzzi

byizzzzzi

0•

コラボレーションツール

Orchestrates autonomous multi-expert debates to analyze complex decisions and reach evidence-based convergence.

The Arena skill transforms Claude Code into a sophisticated decision-making engine by launching a panel of autonomous experts who debate directly with one another. Instead of a single-perspective answer, it recruits 3-5 distinct personas—including a designated Devil's Advocate—to research context, challenge viewpoints, and cite evidence until they reach a consensus or highlight critical disagreements. This skill is ideal for high-stakes technical architecture, product strategy, or any complex dilemma where objective, multi-faceted analysis is essential for a sound conclusion.

主な機能

01Comprehensive Synthesis Reports: Generates structured documentation including trust levels (WLNK), evidence catalogs, and resolution of contested points.

02Evidence-Based Argumentation: Implements a rigorous scoring system where experts must rate sources for reliability and congruence.

030 GitHub stars

04Dynamic Moderator Monitoring: Features an intelligent moderator that intervenes only to resolve loops, stalls, or off-topic drift.

05Autonomous Multi-Expert Orchestration: Automatically selects and launches 3-5 expert personas tailored to the specific problem domain.

06Parallel Context Research: Deploys dedicated researcher agents to gather technical debt, best practices, and project constraints before debating.

ユースケース

01Strategic Risk Assessment: Analyzing high-stakes business or ethical decisions by simulating perspectives from industry experts and critics.

02Product Strategy & Prioritization: Debating feature roadmaps among competing business, user, and technical requirements.

03Architectural Decision Records: Evaluating major changes in a codebase to identify potential tech debt and long-term consequences.

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add izzzzzi/izteam arena

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT