Journal of Marketing Review Process Guide
Interprets Journal of Marketing review processes and decision letters to guide revision planning and editorial compliance.
The Journal of Marketing Review Process skill helps academic researchers understand and navigate the complete peer review lifecycle at the Journal of Marketing (JM). It provides actionable frameworks for parsing Coeditor decision letters, categorizing reviewer feedback into decisive versus secondary concerns, evaluating substantive impact bars, maintaining double-anonymized compliance, and preparing JM Dataverse replication packets upon conditional acceptance. This skill is essential for marketing scholars before submission, during R&R revisions, or when structuring final replication packages.
主な機能
01Differentiates between revision tasks requiring new data/analyses versus conceptual reframing
021,086 GitHub stars
03Parses Coeditor decision letters to isolate must-address priorities from secondary feedback
04Guides preparation for JM Dataverse replication packets and Data Availability Statements
05Clusters reviewer comments by substantive contribution, identification, and managerial relevance
06Enforces double-anonymized review protocols and editorial scope requirements
ユースケース
01Interpreting a major or minor R&R decision letter from the Journal of Marketing Coeditor
02Planning empirical work and revision timelines based on categorized reviewer critiques
03Preparing JM Dataverse replication data, analysis scripts, and Data Availability Statements for conditional acceptance