M&SOM Journal Rebuttal Guide

•
1.1k
•

Guides academic authors through planning revisions and drafting point-by-point rebuttal letters for Manufacturing & Service Operations Management (M&SOM) submissions.

Designed specifically for researchers submitting to Manufacturing & Service Operations Management (M&SOM), this skill structures the entire revise-and-resubmit (R&R) workflow. It prioritizes Department Editor (DE) and Associate Editor (AE) guidance over referee minutiae, helps organize required analytical or empirical work before writing prose, enforces the strict 32-page typeset cap and 16-page online supplement limit, and formats professional point-by-point response letters mapping every critique to exact manuscript locations while maintaining operations centrality.

主な機能

01Structures analytical extensions, robustness checks, and empirical identification updates
02Guides strategic use of the 16-page online supplement for technical proofs and numerical studies
03Prioritizes binding DE and AE feedback over individual referee comments during R&R triage
04Drafts comprehensive point-by-point response letters with precise line and page citations
05Enforces M&SOM manuscript constraints including the 32-page limit and structured abstract format
061,086 GitHub stars

ユースケース

01Triaging decision letters and setting revision roadmaps after receiving an M&SOM major or minor revision
02Drafting structured, respectful point-by-point rebuttal letters citing exact changes and evidence
03Reorganizing complex analytical proofs and empirical robustness checks into the online supplement