Does it simulate specific famous scholars?

No. The skill follows a 'Theory, Not Person' naming convention, focusing on theoretical frameworks (e.g., 'Cultural Capital Perspective') rather than individual people.

What parts of my manuscript can I submit for review?

You can submit full manuscripts, partial drafts, or individual sections. The skill adapts its focus areas (Theory/Methods/Findings) based on the content provided.

Can I choose which theoretical perspectives review my work?

Yes. While the skill automatically identifies perspectives in Phase 0, there is a built-in pause where the user must approve or modify the selected reviewer personas.

Are the reviews saved for later use?

Yes, all generated reviews and synthesis memos are automatically saved as Markdown files in a dedicated 'peer-review-analysis/' folder within your manuscript directory.

Does this skill require a Zotero account?

Yes, this skill requires the Zotero MCP to be configured and connected to your Zotero library containing relevant full-text sources to build accurate reviewer personas.

Peer Reviewer for Researchers

Name: Peer Reviewer for Researchers
Author: nealcaren

bynealcaren

•

データサイエンスとML

Simulates scholarly peer reviews by grounding critiques in specific theoretical and methodological perspectives retrieved from Zotero.

The Peer Reviewer skill helps academics and social researchers strengthen their manuscripts before formal submission by generating high-fidelity simulated reviews. By connecting to a Zotero library, the skill identifies relevant theoretical camps or methodological perspectives, retrieves full-text sources to build informed reviewer personas, and provides constructive feedback focused on theory, methods, and empirical findings. This workflow ensures that critiques are not generic AI outputs but are instead grounded in the actual scholarly literature relevant to the author’s work, helping researchers anticipate blind spots and refine their arguments.

主な機能

01Structured synthesis memos that prioritize revisions and response strategies

02Direct integration with manuscript revision workflows for iterative improvement

03Evidence-based persona construction using Zotero full-text retrieval

04Focused feedback matrix targeting theory, methods, or empirical findings

05Automated identification of 2-3 relevant scholarly reviewer perspectives

069 GitHub stars

ユースケース

01Anticipating critical reviews from specific theoretical schools or camps

02Checking for accurate representation and engagement with cited literature

03Generating pre-submission feedback for academic journal articles

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add nealcaren/social-data-analysis peer-reviewer

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT

Download Skill