What standards does the Critic use to judge a plan?

It checks for file-level citations, concrete testability, existence of file references, and the absence of vague or ambiguous terms.

How does it handle file references?

The skill performs a verification check to ensure that every file reference mentioned in the plan actually exists in your repository, preventing path-related errors.

What is the primary purpose of the Review skill?

The Review skill uses a Critic agent to evaluate proposed development plans, ensuring they are clear, specific, and technically sound before any code is written.

Does the Review skill modify my code directly?

No, it focuses on the planning stage. It provides a verdict of Approved, Revise, or Reject based on the quality of the strategy to ensure the subsequent coding phase is successful.

Plan Review Critic

Name: Plan Review Critic
Author: Yeachan-Heo

byYeachan-Heo

•

2,142

•

生産性とワークフロー

Evaluates and validates implementation plans against rigorous technical standards to ensure clarity, testability, and accuracy.

The Review skill serves as a high-standard quality gate for Claude Code, employing a specialized Critic agent to analyze proposed action plans before execution. By enforcing strict criteria—such as requiring 80% of claims to cite specific file lines and ensuring 90% of acceptance criteria are concrete—it prevents hallucinations and logical errors. This skill acts as an essential pre-flight check, providing actionable feedback and clear verdicts (Approved, Revise, or Reject) to ensure that every development task is grounded in reality and ready for successful implementation.

主な機能

01Structured verdict system: Approved, Revise, or Reject

02Detection of vague terminology and un-testable requirements

03Automated verification of file references and line citations

042,142 GitHub stars

05Rigorous Critic agent evaluation for all proposed plans

06Quantitative standards for plan clarity and specificity

ユースケース

01Ensuring new feature implementations have concrete acceptance criteria

02Checking technical feasibility and file existence for multi-step tasks

03Validating complex architectural refactoring plans before execution

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add yeachan-heo/oh-my-claudecode review

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT

Download Skill