接続

Physical Review Letters Manuscript Revision

brycewang-stanfordbybrycewang-stanford
•
1.1k
•
学習とドキュメンテーション

Guides authors through responding to Physical Review Letters referee reports, structuring point-by-point rebuttals, managing resubmissions, and evaluating APS appeal paths.

The prl-revision skill provides structured, domain-specific guidance for navigating peer review decisions from Physical Review Letters (PRL) and the American Physical Society (APS). It helps researchers draft rigorous, courteous, point-by-point referee response letters, cite specific manuscript modifications, maintain strict PRL length constraints when adding control experiments or explanations, and evaluate whether to resubmit, appeal, or retarget to a specialized Physical Review journal.

主な機能

01Decision strategy evaluation for minor revisions, resubmissions, breadth rejections, and appeals
02Comprehensive pre-submission revision checklist tailored to APS editorial standards
03Structured framework for drafting evidence-based, point-by-point referee response letters
04Concrete reply templates prioritizing physics evidence over defensive rhetoric
05Length-balancing workflows to accommodate new rebuttal text and figures within PRL limits
061,086 GitHub stars

ユースケース

01Rebalancing manuscript text and supplementary material after adding referee-requested control data
02Drafting a courteous, evidence-backed point-by-point response to critical PRL peer review reports
03Evaluating strategic options after an editorial rejection based on broad interest or technical scope