Does it support the GRADE assessment methodology?

Yes, it incorporates GRADE considerations to evaluate the strength of evidence, including criteria for downgrading for risk of bias or upgrading for large effect sizes.

Can it detect p-hacking and statistical errors?

Yes, the skill includes a statistical review checklist to identify issues like underpowered samples, p-value misinterpretation, multiple comparison errors, and p-hacking.

How does this skill evaluate scientific papers?

It uses a systematic framework to assess study design, internal/external validity, measurement quality, and control mechanisms to determine the overall rigor of the research.

Can I use this for systematic reviews?

Absolutely. The skill is designed to help conduct systematic reviews by providing objective tools for evidence quality assessment and risk of bias evaluation.

Scientific Critical Thinking

Name: Scientific Critical Thinking
Author: BbgnsurfTech

byBbgnsurfTech

•

データサイエンスとML

Evaluates research rigor and methodology through systematic assessment of statistical validity, biases, and evidence quality.

This skill provides a structured framework for the critical analysis of scientific claims and research papers. It enables Claude to meticulously evaluate experimental designs, identify potential biases (selection, measurement, and analysis), and assess statistical validity including power analysis and p-value interpretation. By incorporating industry-standard frameworks like GRADE and Cochrane Risk of Bias, this skill helps users determine the strength of evidence and identify logical fallacies, ensuring that conclusions are grounded in rigorous scientific methodology.

主な機能

01Systematic detection of cognitive, selection, and analysis biases

023 GitHub stars

03Comprehensive methodology and experimental design critique

04Statistical evaluation including power analysis and effect size review

05Integration with scientific-schematics for automated diagram generation

06Evidence quality assessment using GRADE and Cochrane ROB frameworks

ユースケース

01Conducting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of existing literature

02Identifying logical fallacies and p-hacking in scientific publications

03Evaluating the internal and external validity of clinical trial protocols

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add bbgnsurftech/claude-skills-collection scientific-critical-thinking

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT

Download Skill