How does this skill handle author bias?

The skill automatically spawns a fresh subagent for the review process, ensuring the reviewer does not share the same context, assumptions, or 'intent' as the initial drafter.

What output does the Writing Review skill produce?

It generates a .claude/REVIEW.md file which contains a structured, multi-level diagnosis intended to be consumed by the /writing-revise command.

Can it handle different writing styles?

Yes, it supports specific style modules for legal, economic, and general writing, loading unique constraints and domain-specific rules for each.

Why is a 3-level review necessary?

It ensures that individual sections are sound (Level 1), transitions between them are logical (Level 2), and the overall document aligns with the initial thesis and outline (Level 3).

What is the 'Iron Law of Reading' in this skill?

It is a non-negotiable requirement that every review comment must cite and quote specific text from the draft to ensure feedback is actionable and grounded in the actual content.

Writing Reviewer

Name: Writing Reviewer
Author: edwinhu

byedwinhu

•

コンテンツ管理

Performs hierarchical, evidence-based reviews of drafted documents to diagnose structural and transitional issues.

The Writing Review skill provides a rigorous, multi-level diagnostic framework for evaluating long-form prose within Claude Code. By enforcing strict 'Iron Laws' of reading and evidence, it ensures every critique is backed by specific quotes from the draft, eliminating vague feedback. The skill operates across three levels—individual sections, transitions between sections, and whole-document coherence—producing a structured REVIEW.md file that guides subsequent revisions. It uniquely utilizes fresh subagents to eliminate author bias and supports domain-specific constraints for legal, economic, or general writing styles.

主な機能

01Evidence-based 'Iron Law' critiques requiring direct quotes for every claim.

02Integration with writing-revise for automated document improvement.

035 GitHub stars

04Hierarchical 3-level review process: Section, Transition, and Document-wide.

05Domain-specific style support for legal, economic, and general prose.

06Automated subagent spawning to ensure objective, unbiased feedback.

ユースケース

01Drafting complex legal or economic papers requiring strict adherence to style guides.

02Identifying 'AI writing smells' and weak transitions in long-form content.

03Technical documentation review for structural consistency and logical flow.

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add edwinhu/workflows writing-review

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT

Download Skill