What is the primary purpose of the Agent Skill Reviewer?

It provides a structured framework to audit, review, and improve the quality and effectiveness of Claude Code skills to ensure they meet standard requirements.

Can I use this for team code reviews?

Yes, it is specifically designed for reviewing skill-related PRs and includes feedback templates and severity guidelines to standardize team communication.

How does this skill evaluate other agent skills?

It evaluates skills across four dimensions: Correctness (spec requirements), Clarity (unambiguous instructions), Effectiveness (triggering/guidance), and Maintainability (organization).

Does it help fix skills that aren't working?

Yes, the skill includes improvement patterns with before-and-after examples to help troubleshoot and resolve common effectiveness issues.

What kind of anti-patterns does it detect?

It identifies issues like rubber-stamping, style-only focus, lack of actionable feedback, and inconsistent severity classification during the review process.

Agent Skill Reviewer

Name: Agent Skill Reviewer
Author: bitsydarel

bybitsydarel

0•

협업 도구

Evaluates and optimizes Claude Code skills to ensure they meet high standards of clarity, effectiveness, and structural compliance.

The Agent Skill Reviewer provides a systematic framework for auditing and improving agent-based skills, ensuring they adhere to the agent-skills standard and performance benchmarks. By analyzing skills across four critical dimensions—correctness, clarity, effectiveness, and maintainability—this tool helps developers identify common anti-patterns and provides actionable feedback for pull requests. Whether you are troubleshooting underperforming skills or standardizing a repository, this skill streamlines the review process with checklists, improvement patterns, and structured feedback templates.

주요 기능

01Automated structure and frontmatter validation

02Guidance for fixing common skill performance issues

03Multi-dimensional quality assessment (Correctness, Clarity, Effectiveness, Maintainability)

04Pre-built feedback templates for Pull Requests

050 GitHub stars

06Anti-pattern identification and detection methods

사용 사례

01Auditing existing agent skills for compliance with organizational standards

02Providing structured feedback on skill-related pull requests

03Troubleshooting and improving underperforming or poorly triggered skills

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add bitsydarel/bdskills bd-skill-reviewing

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT

Download Skill