What happens when a task reaches the maximum retry limit?

The skill triggers an 'Escalate' protocol, providing a summary of all failed attempts and specific options for the user to resolve the blocker.

Can this skill handle complex revision loops?

Yes, it includes a Review Decision Matrix and iteration limits that determine whether a task should be approved, sent back for revision, or escalated for human intervention.

How does it help with security and error handling?

The Code Quality dimension assigns high weight to security vulnerabilities and medium weight to proper error handling like try/catch blocks and null checks.

What dimensions does the Review Criteria skill evaluate?

It evaluates code across five specific dimensions: Completeness, Acceptance Criteria (AC), Code Quality, Integration, and Output Completeness (checking for placeholders like TODOs).

Is it compatible with different programming languages?

While the framework is general-purpose, it includes specialized quality checks for JavaScript, TypeScript, React, and Backend API development.

Code Review Criteria & QA

Name: Code Review Criteria & QA
Author: DUTSTECH

byDUTSTECH

0•

협업 도구

Automates and standardizes the review process for code outputs using a multi-dimensional quality framework.

The Review Criteria skill provides a structured framework for evaluating code submissions across five critical dimensions: completeness, adherence to acceptance criteria, code quality, integration compatibility, and output finality. Designed for environments where Claude acts as a lead reviewer or 'CEO' overseeing other workers, it ensures every piece of code meets high standards before approval. The skill includes automated decision matrices, detailed feedback templates for revisions, and escalation protocols for complex issues, making it an essential tool for maintaining codebase integrity in AI-driven development workflows.

주요 기능

01Automated decision matrix for Approved, Needs Revision, or Escalate statuses

02Configurable iteration limits and escalation protocols for persistent failures

03Five-dimensional review framework covering Completeness, AC, Quality, Integration, and Output

04Language-specific quality standards for JavaScript, TypeScript, React, and Backend APIs

05Standardized feedback templates for clear, actionable developer instructions

060 GitHub stars

사용 사례

01Enforcing consistent coding standards and patterns across distributed teams

02Validating AI-generated code snippets against project-specific acceptance criteria

03Automating pull request reviews within an AI-agent development swarm

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add dutstech/ceoralph review-criteria

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT

Download Skill