How does Claude handle unclear feedback with this skill?

It follows a 'stop and ask' protocol, requesting clarification for all items before starting any implementation to prevent partial or incorrect work.

When will Claude push back on a suggestion?

Claude will push back if a suggestion breaks existing functionality, violates YAGNI principles, lacks context, or conflicts with established architectural decisions.

Does this work with GitHub PR comments?

Yes, it includes specific patterns for replying within inline GitHub comment threads to ensure communication remains organized and contextual.

What is the YAGNI check in this skill?

It involves searching the codebase to see if a suggested feature is actually used. If it's unused, the skill suggests removing it rather than 'implementing it properly'.

Why does this skill discourage saying 'thank you'?

To prioritize technical action over performative agreement. In professional code review, the code itself should demonstrate that the feedback was heard and correctly implemented.

Code Review Reception

Name: Code Review Reception
Author: dazeb

bydazeb

•

협업 도구

Processes code review feedback with technical rigor to ensure high-quality implementations without performative agreement.

The Code Review Reception skill transforms how Claude handles feedback by prioritizing technical verification and architectural integrity over social politeness. It establishes a structured workflow for reading, understanding, and verifying suggestions against the actual codebase before implementation. By enforcing a 'verify-before-implementing' mindset and strictly discouraging performative praise or blind agreement, it ensures that every change is technically sound, adheres to YAGNI (You Aren't Gonna Need It) principles, and aligns perfectly with the existing project context.

주요 기능

01Automated verification of suggestions against codebase reality and YAGNI

024 GitHub stars

03Structured response pattern for systematic feedback processing

04Rigorous clarification protocol for ambiguous or conflicting feedback

05Context-aware pushback strategies based on technical reasoning

06Strict elimination of performative language and unnecessary gratitude

사용 사례

01Handling vague or high-level technical instructions from human partners

02Evaluating suggested 'professional' features for actual necessity and usage

03Processing complex pull request reviews from multiple external contributors

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add dazeb/claudeplaybook receiving-code-review

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT

Download Skill