What feedback format does the Design Critique skill use?

It utilizes the 'I notice, I wonder, What if' framework. This method separates observations from judgments and encourages exploratory suggestions rather than prescriptive demands.

How does this skill prevent 'design by committee'?

The skill enforces a structured framework that ties all feedback directly to pre-defined project goals and user needs, ensuring that critiques remain objective and focused on the problem rather than subjective opinions.

Does this skill help with post-meeting follow-ups?

Absolutely. It includes a specific 'After the Critique' phase designed to help the designer summarize takeaways and document clear action items with assigned owners and deadlines.

Can I use this for different types of design meetings?

Yes, the skill includes specialized logic for various review types, including informal 1-on-1 desk crits, structured team reviews, cross-team sessions, and high-level stakeholder approvals.

Design Critique

Name: Design Critique
Author: Owl-Listener

byOwl-Listener

•

699

•

협업 도구

Facilitates structured design reviews using professional frameworks to generate actionable feedback and improve UI/UX outcomes.

The Design Critique skill transforms Claude into an expert facilitator for product design reviews, ensuring teams move beyond subjective opinions toward goal-oriented outcomes. It provides a comprehensive structure for every phase of the critique process—from setting initial context and constraints to capturing decision-making and action items. By implementing specific feedback formats like 'I notice' and 'I wonder,' this skill helps maintain a constructive environment that focuses on user needs and project objectives rather than personal preferences.

주요 기능

01699 GitHub stars

02Standardized feedback formats (I notice, I wonder, What if) to maintain objectivity

03Structured facilitation frameworks for before, during, and after critiques

04Automated documentation of decisions and action items with owners and deadlines

05Support for multiple review types including desk crits, team crits, and stakeholder reviews

06Proactive avoidance of common pitfalls like design-by-committee and lack of direction

사용 사례

01Facilitating a formal weekly team design review to ensure high-quality UI/UX standards

02Preparing for high-stakes stakeholder reviews by aligning feedback with business goals and user needs

03Getting quick, structured feedback on a specific component or interaction flow during a 'desk crit'

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add owl-listener/designer-skills design-critique

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT

주요 기능

01699 GitHub stars

02Standardized feedback formats (I notice, I wonder, What if) to maintain objectivity

03Structured facilitation frameworks for before, during, and after critiques

04Automated documentation of decisions and action items with owners and deadlines

05Support for multiple review types including desk crits, team crits, and stakeholder reviews

06Proactive avoidance of common pitfalls like design-by-committee and lack of direction

사용 사례

01Facilitating a formal weekly team design review to ensure high-quality UI/UX standards

02Preparing for high-stakes stakeholder reviews by aligning feedback with business goals and user needs

03Getting quick, structured feedback on a specific component or interaction flow during a 'desk crit'