ICSE Author Response & Major Revision
Drafts targeted author rebuttals and structured Major Revision response letters tailored to ICSE peer review criteria.
ICSE Author Response is a specialized skill designed for software engineering researchers navigating the two-turn ICSE review process: the initial pre-decision author response and the post-decision Major Revision letter. It offers structured guidance to address reviewer critiques mapped directly to ICSE core criteria—novelty, rigor, relevance, and verifiability. The skill helps authors construct itemized change ledgers, calibrate an objective and technical-neutral tone, prioritize tasks across a four-week revision sprint, and avoid critical anti-patterns like artifact drift and unkept promises.
주요 기능
01Criterion-targeted response mapping for ICSE pillars (novelty, rigor, relevance, verifiability)
02Four-week revision sprint triage framework to optimize evidence generation and paper updates
03Itemized ledger structuring with section pointers, change descriptions, and reasoned declines
04Dual-turn review strategies for pre-decision rebuttals and Major Revision response letters
051,079 GitHub stars
06Tone calibration guides to eliminate defensive phrasing and maintain academic credibility
사용 사례
01Structuring itemized response ledgers and change-tracking documentation for Major Revision submissions
02Drafting concise author rebuttals during the ICSE review discussion window to correct factual misreadings
03Triaging reviewer feedback to plan compute-heavy baselines and framing revisions within tight deadlines