Can this framework be used with any programming language?

Yes, the framework is ecosystem-agnostic, focusing on universal principles of logic, integrity, and maintainability applicable to any codebase.

What are the severity tiers used in this framework?

Findings are categorized into three tiers: MUST FIX (blocks merge), FIX NOW (mandatory inline fix), or CREATE ISSUE (valid concern requiring separate tracking).

What are the exit criteria for a PR to be considered ready?

A PR is 'Ready to merge' only when zero MUST FIX and zero FIX NOW items remain, and all CREATE ISSUE items have been successfully filed as tracked issues.

How does the 'Inline-First' principle work?

It prioritizes fixing issues within the current PR if the fix is contained within files already in the diff and doesn't expand the PR's scope, reducing administrative overhead.

Does this skill help with GitHub issue tracking?

Yes, it includes a specific protocol to query, create, or append to consolidated 'review-followup' issues using the GitHub CLI to ensure feedback is never lost.

PR Review Framework

Name: PR Review Framework
Author: Kiwi-Home

byKiwi-Home

0•

협업 도구

Implements a structured, severity-tiered framework for pull request evaluations to ensure high code quality and clear exit criteria.

The PR Review Framework skill provides Claude with a standardized methodology for conducting professional-grade code reviews within the Claude Code environment. It utilizes a sophisticated three-tier severity system—MUST FIX, FIX NOW, and CREATE ISSUE—to categorize findings based on their impact and the complexity of the required resolution. By enforcing strict exit criteria and a consolidated issue-creation protocol, this skill ensures that reviews remain objective and actionable while preventing scope creep. It covers four critical evaluation pillars: Correctness, Integrity, Compliance, and Quality, making it an essential tool for maintaining high standards in any software project.

주요 기능

01Consolidated 'CREATE ISSUE' protocol for automated follow-up tracking

02Inline-First disposition framework to minimize issue tracking overhead

030 GitHub stars

04Four-pillar evaluation covering Correctness, Integrity, Compliance, and Quality

05Severity-tiered finding classification for clear prioritization

06Dual iteration modes for comprehensive initial reviews and focused verification

사용 사례

01Standardizing code review quality and consistency across engineering teams

02Automating the categorization of PR feedback in CLI-based workflows

03Ensuring non-blocking technical debt is tracked without delaying critical merges

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add kiwi-home/ai-coding-resources pr-review

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT

Download Skill