Does it generate visual aids for my research?

Yes, it integrates with the scientific-schematics skill to automatically generate, review, and refine publication-quality diagrams and flowcharts.

Can this skill help with journal submissions?

Yes, it benchmarks work against top-tier publication standards, identifies critical weaknesses, and provides a 'Publication Readiness' assessment.

What is the ScholarEval framework?

ScholarEval is a peer-reviewed methodology that assesses research ideas based on soundness (empirical validity) and contribution (advancement relative to existing literature).

How does it handle different academic fields?

The skill is designed to adjust its evaluation criteria based on disciplinary norms, such as emphasizing reproducibility in STEM or argumentation in the humanities.

Scholar Evaluation

Name: Scholar Evaluation
Author: plurigrid

byplurigrid

•

학습 및 문서화

Evaluates scholarly research and academic papers using the systematic ScholarEval framework to ensure rigor, quality, and publication readiness.

The Scholar Evaluation skill implements the ScholarEval framework to provide a structured methodology for assessing academic work, including research papers, proposals, and literature reviews. It systematically evaluates content across eight core dimensions—ranging from problem formulation and methodology to data analysis and writing quality—delivering both qualitative feedback and quantitative scoring. Designed for researchers, academics, and students, it helps identify critical gaps, benchmark against publication standards, and can even trigger the generation of publication-quality scientific schematics to enhance visual communication.

주요 기능

01Integration with scientific-schematics for automated diagram and figure generation

02Quantitative scoring on a 5-point scale for benchmarking research quality

03Context-aware assessments tailored to specific disciplines and development stages

04Dimension-based evaluation covering methodology, literature review, and analytical rigor

058 GitHub stars

06Actionable, prioritized feedback structured for immediate manuscript revision

사용 사례

01Pre-submission peer review for journal articles and conference papers

02Evaluating student theses or dissertations for academic quality and logical flow

03Assessing the rigor and feasibility of research proposals or grant applications

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add plurigrid/asi scholar-evaluation

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT

Download Skill