What disciplines is the Scholar Evaluation skill suitable for?

It is designed to be adaptable across STEM, Social Sciences, and Humanities, adjusting its evaluation criteria based on discipline-specific norms.

Does it support the creation of visual diagrams?

Yes, it integrates with the scientific-schematics skill to generate publication-quality diagrams, flowcharts, and technical schematics to accompany your evaluation.

Can this skill help prepare papers for journal submission?

Yes, it identifies gaps in methodology, literature review, and writing clarity, providing a roadmap to improve the document's readiness for target publication venues.

What is the ScholarEval framework used by this skill?

ScholarEval is a retrieval-augmented evaluation framework that assesses research ideas and manuscripts based on empirical validity, soundness, and grounding in existing literature.

Scholar Evaluation

Name: Scholar Evaluation
Author: oimiragieo

byoimiragieo

•

데이터 과학 및 ML

Evaluates research papers and scholarly work using the ScholarEval framework to provide structured feedback and quantitative quality scoring.

The Scholar Evaluation skill enables researchers and academics to systematically assess the quality of scholarly documents using the peer-reviewed ScholarEval framework. It provides a comprehensive analysis across eight critical dimensions, including research methodology, literature synthesis, and data integrity. By generating prioritized, actionable feedback and quantitative scores, this tool helps users identify critical weaknesses, benchmark research quality, and prepare manuscripts for high-impact publication venues. It also integrates seamlessly with scientific schematic tools to enhance the visual presentation of research concepts.

주요 기능

01Automated calculation of aggregate scores for objective benchmarking

0217 GitHub stars

03Actionable, prioritized feedback for improving publication readiness

04Quantitative scoring across 8 core scholarly quality dimensions on a 5-point scale

05Multi-dimensional assessment of research methodology and problem formulation

06Integration with scientific schematic generation for visual data representation

사용 사례

01Performing pre-submission peer reviews for academic manuscripts and journal articles

02Providing structured feedback to students on theses, dissertations, or literature reviews

03Assessing the rigor and feasibility of research proposals or grant applications

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add oimiragieo/agent-studio scholar-evaluation

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT

Download Skill