Which reporting standards does it support?

The skill includes guidelines for major standards such as CONSORT, STROBE, PRISMA, ARRIVE, and more to ensure comprehensive compliance in reporting.

Does it help with figures and diagrams?

It integrates with the scientific-schematics skill to generate and refine publication-quality diagrams that illustrate complex research workflows or results.

Is it suitable for grant reviews?

Absolutely, it provides specific assessment criteria for evaluating the feasibility, significance, and methodological rigor of grant applications across various disciplines.

Can it evaluate statistical methods?

Yes, it assesses statistical assumptions, power analysis, p-values, effect sizes, and the appropriateness of the tests used in a study.

What is the Peer Review skill?

It is a specialized capability for Claude Code designed to help researchers evaluate scientific papers and grant proposals using a structured, rigorous methodology.

Scientific Peer Review

Name: Scientific Peer Review
Author: Yezez9

byYezez9

0•

데이터 과학 및 ML

Conducts rigorous, checklist-based evaluations of scientific manuscripts and grant proposals to ensure methodological and statistical validity.

This skill provides a comprehensive framework for professional peer review, guiding users through a multi-stage assessment of scientific research. It evaluates everything from initial novelty and scope to detailed methodological rigor, statistical accuracy, and adherence to reporting standards like CONSORT or STROBE. By utilizing a structured workflow, it helps reviewers identify critical flaws, verify data integrity, and provide constructive, publication-grade feedback while integrating visual schematics to illustrate complex research concepts.

주요 기능

010 GitHub stars

02Compliance checking for international reporting standards (CONSORT, PRISMA, STROBE)

03Integration with scientific-schematics for visual data representation

04Ethics and research integrity evaluation including IRB and animal welfare

05Structured 7-stage review workflow for manuscripts and grants

06Methodological and statistical rigor assessment checklists

사용 사례

01Internal pre-submission review of manuscripts to identify weaknesses

02Writing formal peer review reports for academic journals

03Evaluating grant proposals for methodological soundness and feasibility

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add yezez9/research-agent peer-review

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT