How does it handle statistical analysis assessment?

The skill evaluates statistical assumptions, sample size justifications, effect sizes, and whether appropriate corrections for multiple comparisons were applied.

Does it support specific reporting standards?

Yes, it includes checks for major reporting guidelines such as CONSORT, STROBE, PRISMA, and ARRIVE to ensure manuscripts meet international standards.

What is the Peer Review skill for?

It is a specialized toolkit for Claude Code designed to help researchers and reviewers systematically evaluate scientific manuscripts and grant proposals for technical and ethical soundness.

Can I use it to improve my own research paper?

Absolutely. It serves as an excellent self-assessment tool to identify potential gaps in methodology, statistics, or literature coverage before you submit to a journal.

Scientific Peer Review Toolkit

Name: Scientific Peer Review Toolkit
Author: lifangda

bylifangda

•

데이터 과학 및 ML

Provides a systematic framework for evaluating the methodology, statistics, and integrity of scientific manuscripts and grant proposals.

소개

The Scientific Peer Review Toolkit is a specialized Claude Code skill designed to automate and standardize the critical evaluation of academic research. It guides users through a multi-stage workflow that assesses everything from initial novelty to deep statistical rigor, reproducibility, and ethical compliance. By implementing discipline-specific standards like CONSORT and PRISMA, this skill helps researchers and reviewers identify methodological flaws, verify data integrity, and generate structured, constructive feedback reports for journals or funding agencies.

주요 기능

Deep-dive assessment of statistical rigor and experimental design
16 GitHub stars
Automated generation of prioritized major and minor review comments
Verification of data availability and reproducibility protocols
Systematic section-by-section manuscript evaluation framework
Compliance checking for reporting standards like CONSORT and PRISMA

사용 사례

Conducting professional peer reviews for academic journal submissions
Performing internal pre-submission audits of manuscripts to ensure high reporting standards
Evaluating the technical feasibility and rigor of research grant applications

소개

주요 기능

Deep-dive assessment of statistical rigor and experimental design
16 GitHub stars
Automated generation of prioritized major and minor review comments
Verification of data availability and reproducibility protocols
Systematic section-by-section manuscript evaluation framework
Compliance checking for reporting standards like CONSORT and PRISMA

사용 사례

Conducting professional peer reviews for academic journal submissions
Performing internal pre-submission audits of manuscripts to ensure high reporting standards
Evaluating the technical feasibility and rigor of research grant applications