Technical Code Review Logic FAQs

Question 1

What is the 'YAGNI' check in this context?

Accepted Answer

Before implementing 'proper' features suggested by reviewers, the skill prompts Claude to grep the codebase for actual usage to ensure the added complexity is truly necessary for the current project scope.

Question 2

What happens if Claude pushes back and is later proven wrong?

Accepted Answer

The skill provides a pattern for factual correction, allowing Claude to acknowledge the new technical reality and move straight to implementation without over-explaining or apologizing.

Question 3

How does this skill handle conflicting feedback?

Accepted Answer

It instructs Claude to stop and discuss with the primary human partner if external feedback conflicts with established architectural decisions or prior instructions.

Question 4

Why does this skill forbid saying 'Thank you' or 'Great point'?

Accepted Answer

The skill prioritizes technical action over social performance. By eliminating performative agreement, it ensures that every change is driven by technical verification rather than a desire to seem helpful or agreeable.

Question 5

How does Claude handle unclear review comments?

Accepted Answer

The skill mandates a 'Stop and Ask' protocol. Claude will not implement partial feedback if any part of the review is unclear, preventing fragmented or incorrect changes.

Technical Code Review Logic

주요 기능

사용 사례

Technical Code Review Logic

주요 기능

사용 사례