How does this skill change Claude's communication style?

It shifts Claude's focus from social agreement to technical accuracy, prohibiting performative phrases like 'You're absolutely right' in favor of factual verification.

What happens if a code review comment is unclear?

The skill instructs Claude to stop and ask for clarification on specific items rather than proceeding with a potentially incorrect partial implementation.

Will Claude still implement the requested changes?

Yes, but only after it has verified the technical correctness of the suggestion and ensured it doesn't break existing functionality or violate YAGNI principles.

How does it handle feedback that is technically incorrect?

It provides a framework for Claude to push back using technical reasoning, reference to working tests, and architectural context rather than blind compliance.

Technical Code Review Protocol

Name: Technical Code Review Protocol
Author: axiomantic

byaxiomantic

협업 도구

Applies a rigorous, technical-first approach to processing and implementing code review feedback while eliminating performative agreement.

소개

This skill transforms how Claude handles code reviews by prioritizing technical verification and architectural integrity over social performance. It establishes a strict communication protocol that requires thorough verification against the codebase before any implementation, encourages technical pushback against incorrect or unnecessary suggestions (YAGNI), and mandates clarification for ambiguous feedback. By removing social fluff and focusing on factual accuracy, it ensures that changes are only made when they are technically sound, well-understood, and aligned with the project's existing reality.

주요 기능

0 GitHub stars
Built-in YAGNI (You Ain't Gonna Need It) checks for unnecessary feature suggestions
Evidence-based pushback mechanism for technically incorrect or conflicting suggestions
Structured clarification protocol for ambiguous or multi-item feedback sets
Strict verification workflow to validate feedback against codebase reality before implementation
Enforcement of non-performative communication by removing social fluff and gratitude

사용 사례

Processing high-stakes feedback from external security or architectural reviewers
Filtering out scope creep and unnecessary features during the code refinement phase
Managing complex, multi-point feedback loops during large pull request reviews

소개

주요 기능

0 GitHub stars
Built-in YAGNI (You Ain't Gonna Need It) checks for unnecessary feature suggestions
Evidence-based pushback mechanism for technically incorrect or conflicting suggestions
Structured clarification protocol for ambiguous or multi-item feedback sets
Strict verification workflow to validate feedback against codebase reality before implementation
Enforcement of non-performative communication by removing social fluff and gratitude

사용 사례

Processing high-stakes feedback from external security or architectural reviewers
Filtering out scope creep and unnecessary features during the code refinement phase
Managing complex, multi-point feedback loops during large pull request reviews