What is the 'YAGNI' check in this context?

Claude will grep the codebase for actual usage before implementing suggested features to ensure that code is only added if it is truly necessary for the project.

How does it handle unclear feedback?

It mandates that Claude stop and request clarification for all items before implementing any part of the feedback, preventing errors caused by partial understanding.

Why does this skill prohibit saying 'thanks' or 'great point'?

It prioritizes technical focus over social performance, ensuring Claude spends time on verification and implementation rather than unnecessary politeness that can mask technical errors.

How does Claude handle feedback from external reviewers?

It applies a skeptical filter, checking for platform compatibility, potential regressions, and alignment with the project owner's original architectural decisions before proceeding.

What is the protocol for technical pushback?

Pushback is delivered using factual technical reasoning, references to existing tests, and specific questions rather than defensive language.

Technical Code Review Reception

Name: Technical Code Review Reception
Author: ehartye

byehartye

0•

협업 도구

Processes code review feedback with technical rigor by prioritizing verification and correctness over performative agreement.

This skill equips Claude with a structured framework for handling code review suggestions from both project owners and external reviewers. It shifts the focus from social politeness to technical accuracy, ensuring that every change is verified against the codebase and architectural decisions before implementation. By enforcing a 'verify-then-act' workflow and prohibiting performative gratitude, it streamlines the review cycle, prevents the introduction of unnecessary features through YAGNI checks, and ensures that technical pushback is handled with factual reasoning rather than defensiveness.

주요 기능

010 GitHub stars

02Elimination of performative politeness to maintain purely technical focus

03Built-in YAGNI (You Ain't Gonna Need It) verification for new features

04Structured six-step verification workflow for all incoming feedback

05Source-specific handling for project owners vs. external reviewers

06Standardized protocols for technical pushback and clarification

사용 사례

01Resolving ambiguous or multi-part review comments systematically without regressions

02Implementing feedback from project owners while maintaining architectural integrity

03Critically evaluating and filtering suggestions from external open-source contributors

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add ehartye/hartye-superpowers receiving-code-review

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT

Download Skill