How does the skill handle unclear feedback?

It mandates a full stop on implementation until all items are clarified to prevent partial or incorrect changes that might conflict.

Why does this skill discourage saying 'Thank you'?

It prioritizes technical action and clarity over social performance, ensuring the focus remains on code quality and verification rather than politeness.

What is the YAGNI check in this context?

It prompts the AI to verify if a suggested feature is actually used in the codebase before implementing it, preventing unnecessary complexity.

Does this skill work for both human and automated reviews?

Yes, it provides specific handling logic for trusted partners, external reviewers, and automated feedback sources to ensure appropriate skepticism.

Technical Code Review Reception

Name: Technical Code Review Reception
Author: mance-cyber

bymance-cyber

협업 도구

Implements a technically rigorous approach to processing code review feedback by prioritizing verification over performative agreement.

소개

This skill optimizes how Claude handles code review feedback, ensuring technical accuracy and codebase integrity over social niceties. It provides a structured response pattern—read, understand, verify, evaluate, respond, and implement—to prevent the implementation of incorrect or unnecessary suggestions. By enforcing a 'verify before assuming' policy and eliminating performative phrases like 'You're absolutely right,' this skill maintains high technical standards and prevents feature creep through YAGNI (You Ain't Gonna Need It) checks.

주요 기능

Structured response pattern for systematic feedback processing
Context-aware handling for internal vs. external reviewers
0 GitHub stars
YAGNI-based verification for suggested features
Elimination of performative and sycophantic language
Specific protocols for resolving unclear or conflicting feedback

사용 사례

Handling feedback from external reviewers who may lack full codebase context
Maintaining technical discipline in high-stakes environments where 'polite' AI agreement could introduce bugs
Processing complex PR reviews where suggestions might conflict with existing architecture

소개

주요 기능

Structured response pattern for systematic feedback processing
Context-aware handling for internal vs. external reviewers
0 GitHub stars
YAGNI-based verification for suggested features
Elimination of performative and sycophantic language
Specific protocols for resolving unclear or conflicting feedback

사용 사례

Handling feedback from external reviewers who may lack full codebase context
Maintaining technical discipline in high-stakes environments where 'polite' AI agreement could introduce bugs
Processing complex PR reviews where suggestions might conflict with existing architecture