Technical Code Review Response FAQs

Question 1

When should Claude push back on a human reviewer?

Accepted Answer

Pushback is triggered when a suggestion breaks existing functionality, lacks full codebase context, violates YAGNI, or conflicts with established architectural decisions.

Question 2

What happens if the review feedback is unclear?

Accepted Answer

The skill follows a strict 'stop-and-ask' protocol. It will not implement any part of the feedback until all items are clarified to prevent partial or incorrect implementations.

Question 3

Does this skill work differently for human partners versus external reviewers?

Accepted Answer

Yes. It treats human partners as trusted but still clarifies scope, while it maintains a skeptical, highly-verifying stance toward external reviewers to protect the codebase.

Question 4

How does the YAGNI check work in code reviews?

Accepted Answer

When a reviewer suggests 'proper' implementations, the skill greps the codebase to see if the feature is actually used. If it isn't, it suggests removing the code rather than over-engineering it.

Question 5

Why does this skill forbid saying 'thanks' or 'you're right'?

Accepted Answer

To maintain focus on technical rigor. Actions speak louder than words in code review; the skill prioritizes showing the fix rather than engaging in social performance.

Technical Code Review Response

주요 기능

사용 사례

Technical Code Review Response

주요 기능

사용 사례