Can I use Council for Pull Request reviews?

Yes, Council can analyze PR diffs by assigning agents roles like 'Security Reviewer' or 'Performance Expert' to provide a multi-perspective critique of the code changes.

How does Council differ from a standard AI response?

Unlike a single response, Council creates a team of agents with conflicting viewpoints who debate each other using the SendMessage tool to surface hidden risks and nuanced trade-offs.

What is the role of the Step-back Judge?

The Step-back Judge acts as a meta-reviewer who audits the debate's quality and ensures the panelists aren't ignoring critical dimensions or falling into groupthink.

What is the final output of a Council session?

The primary output is a detailed Tradeoff Map which includes an executive summary, contention points, step-back insights, and a decision confidence score.

Does Council use external data?

Yes, it can optionally integrate external LLM opinions via Codex and community sentiment analysis via dev-scan to provide a more holistic view.

Council Multi-Perspective Deliberation

Name: Council Multi-Perspective Deliberation
Author: team-attention

byteam-attention

•

138

•

Collaboration Tools

Orchestrates a dynamic committee of expert agents to facilitate deep technical deliberation and multi-perspective tradeoff mapping.

Council is a sophisticated decision-making framework for Claude Code that moves beyond simple prompting to create a rigorous, adversarial deliberation environment. By dynamically assembling a panel of specialized agents (e.g., Security Analyst, Performance Engineer, DX Advocate), it initiates iterative peer-to-peer debates to uncover hidden risks and complex tradeoffs. A dedicated Step-back Judge audits the discussion for blind spots and logical fallacies, ensuring the final synthesized Tradeoff Map provides a high-confidence foundation for critical architectural and technical decisions.

Key Features

01138 GitHub stars

02External Intelligence Integration: Incorporates external LLM opinions and community sentiment for a broader perspective.

03Step-back Meta-Review: Employs an independent judge to evaluate debate quality and identify missed dimensions.

04Structured Tradeoff Mapping: Produces a comprehensive visual analysis of competing solutions with decision confidence scores.

05Dynamic Committee Assembly: Tailors agent roles and perspectives specifically to the deliberation topic.

06Iterative Peer-to-Peer Debate: Facilitates multi-round interactions where agents challenge and refine each other's positions.

Use Cases

01Comparing competing technologies or frameworks (e.g., choosing a database or state management library).

02Adversarial security and risk assessment for critical pull requests and design documents.

03Conducting high-stakes architectural reviews for migrations, monorepo transitions, or new system designs.

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add team-attention/hoyeon council

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT