CSCW Review Process Guide
Decodes the ACM CSCW journal-model review workflow, decision vocabulary, revision statistics, and rolling editorial timelines.
The CSCW Review Process skill equips academic authors with essential domain intelligence for navigating the PACM HCI journal-model review lifecycle for ACM CSCW. It clarifies ambiguous decision categories such as 'Revise for External Review' and 'Revise and Resubmit (R&R)', explains same-reviewer re-review expectations, and provides structural context on acceptance base rates. Authors can assess where their paper stands in the rolling editorial board pipeline, accurately interpret wait times, and strategically structure second-round revisions and editor correspondence.
Key Features
01Explains same-reviewer re-review mechanics and tracked response obligations
02Provides statistical calibration and base rates from historical review cycles
03Offers milestone-based waiting-time guidelines and standing report templates
04Clarifies PACM HCI and CSCW decision terminology and their direct implications
051,074 GitHub stars
06Guides navigation of the continuous rolling editorial board model (CSCW 2027+)
Use Cases
01Interpreting initial decision letters (R&R vs. Revise for External Review) to plan revision timelines
02Evaluating paper status in the rolling editorial review pipeline and drafting handling editor queries
03Navigating same-reviewer expectations and preparing point-by-point author response strategies