JEL Survey Topic Selection

•
1.1k
•

Evaluates economic literature topics against Journal of Economic Literature publishing standards to determine survey viability, scope, and target venue.

JEL Survey Topic Selection guides researchers and economists in evaluating candidate literature to determine if it fits the rigorous standards of a Journal of Economic Literature (JEL) survey. It applies a four-part fit test covering maturity, broad economic importance, synthesis need, and tractable scope, while distinguishing JEL-appropriate topics from those better suited for JEP or field-specific review sections. By helping you frame a central animating question, identify current catalysts, and sketch core research lines, this skill ensures your survey proposal is publication-ready and avoids common academic anti-patterns.

Key Features

01Evaluates literature against four core JEL criteria: maturity, importance, synthesis need, and tractable scope
021,079 GitHub stars
03Provides a decision framework to route topics between JEL, JEP, and field journal review outlets
04Generates structured coverage skeletons highlighting 3 to 6 essential research lines
05Identifies academic anti-patterns such as premature surveys and self-promotional retrospectives
06Helps formulate the survey's central animating question and 'why-now' justification

Use Cases

01Determining if an emerging or established economic literature is sufficiently mature for a comprehensive JEL survey
02Drafting the topic framing, core questions, and coverage scope ahead of an editorial survey pitch
03Selecting between target review venues like Journal of Economic Literature, Journal of Economic Perspectives, or field journals