Connect

M&SOM Journal Rebuttal Guide

brycewang-stanfordbybrycewang-stanford
•
1.1k
•
Learning & Documentation

Guides academic authors through planning revisions and drafting point-by-point rebuttal letters for Manufacturing & Service Operations Management (M&SOM) submissions.

Designed specifically for researchers submitting to Manufacturing & Service Operations Management (M&SOM), this skill structures the entire revise-and-resubmit (R&R) workflow. It prioritizes Department Editor (DE) and Associate Editor (AE) guidance over referee minutiae, helps organize required analytical or empirical work before writing prose, enforces the strict 32-page typeset cap and 16-page online supplement limit, and formats professional point-by-point response letters mapping every critique to exact manuscript locations while maintaining operations centrality.

Key Features

01Structures analytical extensions, robustness checks, and empirical identification updates
02Guides strategic use of the 16-page online supplement for technical proofs and numerical studies
03Prioritizes binding DE and AE feedback over individual referee comments during R&R triage
04Drafts comprehensive point-by-point response letters with precise line and page citations
05Enforces M&SOM manuscript constraints including the 32-page limit and structured abstract format
061,086 GitHub stars

Use Cases

01Triaging decision letters and setting revision roadmaps after receiving an M&SOM major or minor revision
02Drafting structured, respectful point-by-point rebuttal letters citing exact changes and evidence
03Reorganizing complex analytical proofs and empirical robustness checks into the online supplement