How does the skill handle failed validation checks?

If a plan fails a specific dimension like feasibility or quality, the skill spawns a specialized sub-agent to analyze the problem and presents you with multiple-choice options to fix it interactively.

Does it automatically modify my files?

Yes, once you agree on a refinement option during the interactive session, the skill uses targeted edits to update your plan file with the agreed-upon changes.

When should I use the Plan Reviewer skill?

You should use this skill after you have written an implementation plan but before you start executing the code changes, typically when Claude presents the option to 'review the plan'.

Can this skill detect if I'm adding features not in the original scope?

Yes, the scope creep detector compares your implementation plan against previous research or brainstorming files to ensure the project remains aligned with original requirements.

Plan Reviewer

Name: Plan Reviewer
Author: seanGSISG

byseanGSISG

Productivity & Workflow

Validates and refines implementation plans across completeness, quality, feasibility, and scope dimensions to ensure robust execution.

About

Plan Reviewer is a specialized Claude Code skill designed to scrutinize implementation plans before code execution begins. By automatically assessing plans against four critical dimensions—completeness, quality, feasibility, and scope—it identifies potential risks, vague language, and missing dependencies. If a plan falls short, the skill spawns specialized validator sub-agents to perform deep-dive analysis and then guides the user through an interactive refinement process to resolve issues, ensuring every task is actionable and aligned with original project goals.

Key Features

Multi-dimensional validation of completeness, quality, feasibility, and scope
Interactive Q&A refinement loop for real-time plan optimization
Deep technical verification of file paths and dependencies using MCP tools
0 GitHub stars
Automated specialized sub-agent escalation for deep-dive analysis
Automatic targeted plan file updates based on user-approved decisions

Use Cases

Preventing scope creep by comparing current implementation tasks against project brainstorms
Reviewing complex multi-phase implementation plans for technical accuracy and feasibility
Ensuring robust testing strategies and rollback plans are defined before starting work

About

Key Features

Multi-dimensional validation of completeness, quality, feasibility, and scope
Interactive Q&A refinement loop for real-time plan optimization
Deep technical verification of file paths and dependencies using MCP tools
0 GitHub stars
Automated specialized sub-agent escalation for deep-dive analysis
Automatic targeted plan file updates based on user-approved decisions

Use Cases

Preventing scope creep by comparing current implementation tasks against project brainstorms
Reviewing complex multi-phase implementation plans for technical accuracy and feasibility
Ensuring robust testing strategies and rollback plans are defined before starting work