Can this skill generate visual diagrams for my research?

Yes, it integrates with scientific-schematics to automatically generate publication-quality figures, workflow diagrams, and methodology flowcharts based on your text.

Is this skill suitable for all academic disciplines?

While grounded in general scholarly rigor, the skill allows for adjustments based on disciplinary norms in STEM, Social Sciences, and the Humanities.

Does it provide quantitative scores for research quality?

Yes, it provides a 5-point scale assessment for multiple dimensions like methodology, writing, and analysis, including an automated script for calculating aggregate scores.

What is the ScholarEval framework used by this skill?

ScholarEval is a research-backed framework that evaluates scholarly work based on soundness (empirical validity) and contribution (the degree of advancement relative to prior research).

Scholar Evaluation

Name: Scholar Evaluation
Author: BbgnsurfTech

byBbgnsurfTech

•

Data Science & ML

Systematically evaluates research papers and scholarly work using the ScholarEval framework for rigorous academic assessment.

Scholar Evaluation is a specialized skill that implements the ScholarEval framework to provide structured, objective assessments of academic research. It evaluates documents across eight critical dimensions—including methodology, literature review, and analytical rigor—to offer both qualitative feedback and quantitative scoring. Designed for researchers, reviewers, and students, this skill identifies critical weaknesses, suggests improvements, and assesses publication readiness. It also integrates with scientific-schematics to automatically generate publication-quality diagrams that enhance the visual communication of complex scholarly findings.

Key Features

01Prioritized, actionable feedback mapped to specific document sections

02Comprehensive publication readiness benchmarking for journals and conferences

03Quantitative scoring (1-5 scale) with automated aggregate calculation scripts

04Multi-dimensional assessment of research rigor, soundness, and contribution

05Integrated scientific schematic generation for publication-quality visuals

063 GitHub stars

Use Cases

01Pre-submission peer review of academic manuscripts to identify gaps

02Assessing the comprehensiveness and quality of research proposals or literature reviews

03Benchmarking student work or internal research against established scholarly standards

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add bbgnsurftech/claude-skills-collection scholar-evaluation

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT

Download Skill