How does it handle statistical analysis review?

It assesses whether statistical assumptions are met, checks for appropriate test selection, verifies power calculations, and ensures effect sizes and confidence intervals are reported.

Does this skill check for specific reporting guidelines?

Yes, it is designed to evaluate compliance with major international standards including CONSORT, STROBE, PRISMA, ARRIVE, and more.

Does it assist with data visualization?

Yes, it integrates with scientific-schematics to generate and refine diagrams, flowcharts, and technical illustrations for your review or manuscript.

Can I use this for grant proposal reviews?

Absolutely. The skill includes specific workflows for evaluating grant applications, focusing on significance, innovation, and methodological soundness.

Scientific Peer Review & Evaluation

Name: Scientific Peer Review & Evaluation
Author: hyperbolic-c

byhyperbolic-c

•

Learning & Documentation

Conducts structured scientific manuscript and grant reviews using rigorous methodology assessments and reporting standards.

This skill empowers Claude to perform high-level scientific peer reviews by following a systematic, multi-stage evaluation process. It covers everything from initial abstract assessment to deep-dives into methodological rigor, statistical validity, and ethical compliance. Ideal for researchers, journal editors, and grant applicants, it ensures manuscripts adhere to international reporting standards like CONSORT and STROBE while providing constructive, actionable feedback to improve scientific communication, transparency, and reproducibility.

Key Features

01Evaluation of research ethics, data availability, and reproducibility standards

02Automated generation of publication-quality scientific schematics and diagrams

03Compliance checking for reporting standards like CONSORT, STROBE, and PRISMA

04In-depth statistical assessment including power analysis and significance testing

05Structured 7-stage peer review workflow for journals and grants

061 GitHub stars

Use Cases

01Drafting formal, constructive peer review reports for academic journals

02Performing pre-submission critiques of grant proposals to identify methodological gaps

03Internal auditing of research manuscripts to ensure compliance with reporting guidelines

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add hyperbolic-c/auto-writing peer-review

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT

Download Skill