Does it require manual setup?

It requires a Python environment with the sibyl-orchestrate package and a pre-configured workspace path to function correctly.

Where does the skill save the review feedback?

The skill writes critiques to a specific path within your workspace, typically located at writing/critique/[section_id]_critique.md.

What is the primary purpose of Sibyl Section Critic?

It serves as an automated agent that reviews specific chapters or sections of a document, providing critical feedback to help authors improve their work.

Can I use it for general technical documentation?

While optimized for academic sections, it can be used for any structured writing project that follows the expected workspace file structure.

Is this skill part of a larger system?

Yes, it is part of the Sibyl-Codex repository and is designed to work with the sibyl-light agent and specific workspace environments.

Sibyl Section Critic

Name: Sibyl Section Critic
Author: qcai0427

byqcai0427

0•

Learning & Documentation

Reviews and critiques specific sections of academic papers or technical documents to improve logical flow and quality.

Sibyl Section Critic is a specialized Claude Code skill designed for researchers and technical writers working within the Sibyl-Codex ecosystem. It automates the iterative review process by analyzing individual document sections and generating structured critiques in Markdown format. By reading specific section IDs from a workspace and outputting feedback to a dedicated critique directory, it helps authors identify weaknesses in their arguments, stylistic inconsistencies, and structural gaps before final submission.

Key Features

01Integration with Sibyl-Codex workspace structures

02Generates detailed critique files in Markdown

030 GitHub stars

04Targeted analysis of specific section IDs

05Streamlined academic writing and peer-review simulation

06Automated section-by-section review and feedback

Use Cases

01Iterative drafting of academic research papers

02Standardizing feedback for collaborative writing projects

03Reviewing technical documentation for clarity and completeness

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add qcai0427/sibyl-codex sibyl-section-critic

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT

Key Features

01Integration with Sibyl-Codex workspace structures

02Generates detailed critique files in Markdown

030 GitHub stars

04Targeted analysis of specific section IDs

05Streamlined academic writing and peer-review simulation

06Automated section-by-section review and feedback

Use Cases

01Iterative drafting of academic research papers

02Standardizing feedback for collaborative writing projects

03Reviewing technical documentation for clarity and completeness

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add qcai0427/sibyl-codex sibyl-section-critic

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT