How do I provide feedback on the review results?

The skill generates a plan review file with '[ ]' placeholders. You type your feedback directly into the file, which the skill then reads to update your plan.

Does this skill automatically update my source code?

No, it focuses on the planning phase. It modifies your plan files based on your feedback to ensure the strategy is sound before code implementation starts.

How does the skill find my implementation plans?

It searches your project's memory directory for files matching the 'plan - *.md' pattern and identifies incomplete plans for review.

What criteria does the skill use to evaluate a plan?

It evaluates plans for completeness against specs, logical ordering of dependencies, task granularity, ambiguity, and potential technical risks.

Spec-Driven Plan Review

Name: Spec-Driven Plan Review
Author: agenticnotetaking

byagenticnotetaking

•

Productivity & Workflow

Conducts a rigorous pre-implementation audit of development plans to identify gaps, risks, and missing dependencies.

The Plan Review skill is a core component of the Eidos spec-driven development workflow, designed to catch errors before implementation begins. It analyzes existing plans stored in your project's memory against technical specifications and prior design decisions to ensure logical sequencing, appropriate task granularity, and total requirement coverage. By generating a dedicated review artifact with structured feedback placeholders, it facilitates a 'write-first' communication style that minimizes rework and ensures the AI and developer are perfectly aligned on the implementation path.

Key Features

01Structured Markdown review generation with phase-by-phase findings

02Human-in-the-loop feedback slots using interactive artifact placeholders

03Automated plan analysis against linked project specifications and requirements

0441 GitHub stars

05Logical dependency checking to ensure implementation steps are correctly sequenced

06Automatic plan refinement based on user-provided review feedback

Use Cases

01Refining ambiguous plan steps into actionable tasks before starting a coding session

02Validating implementation sequences for database migrations and API changes

03Auditing complex feature roadmaps to ensure edge cases and setup steps are included

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add agenticnotetaking/eidos plan-review

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT

Key Features

01Structured Markdown review generation with phase-by-phase findings

02Human-in-the-loop feedback slots using interactive artifact placeholders

03Automated plan analysis against linked project specifications and requirements

0441 GitHub stars

05Logical dependency checking to ensure implementation steps are correctly sequenced

06Automatic plan refinement based on user-provided review feedback

Use Cases

01Refining ambiguous plan steps into actionable tasks before starting a coding session

02Validating implementation sequences for database migrations and API changes

03Auditing complex feature roadmaps to ensure edge cases and setup steps are included