连接

AAAG Journal Review Process

brycewang-stanfordbybrycewang-stanford
•
1.1k
•
学习与文档

Guides authors through the editorial review workflow, area editor routing, and desk-reject screening for the Annals of the American Association of Geographers.

The AAAG Review Process skill equips academic authors with clear guidance on how the Annals of the American Association of Geographers evaluates manuscript submissions. It breaks down the double-anonymous peer review model across its four primary domain areas—Geographic Methods, Human Geography, Nature and Society, and Physical Geography/Earth & Environmental Sciences—along with General Geography and Cartography tracks. By identifying common desk-reject triggers, area-specific reviewer expectations, and strategic paths for interpreting revision decisions, this skill ensures manuscripts are properly positioned and stress-tested before submission or formal rebuttal.

主要功能

01Provides a desk-reject self-screen matrix targeting word counts, formatting, and spatial methodology
02Includes standardized pre-submission checklists to ensure double-anonymity and cartographic rigor
03Maps editorial structure across all major AAAG subject areas and specialty editors
04Details decision letter interpretations for acceptances, major revisions (R&R), and rejections
05Outlines domain-specific reviewer expectations for methods, human, physical, and nature-society tracks
061,069 GitHub stars

使用场景

01Selecting the appropriate subject area track to ensure correct editor and referee routing
02Interpreting major revision (R&R) decision letters to plan an effective rebuttal strategy
03Pre-submission stress-testing to eliminate desk-reject risks before uploading to Editorial Manager