Does this skill work for code reviews?

No, this skill is intended for high-level business logic, strategies, and plans. For technical debugging, it is recommended to use standard code review tools.

What languages are supported?

The skill automatically detects your input language (defaulting to Danish if ambiguous) and provides the full critique and synthesis in that language.

What is the Brutal Review skill?

Brutal Review is a Claude Code plugin that provides uncompromising, honest feedback on business ideas, plans, and strategies using multiple critical personas.

Can I request a specific type of critique?

Yes, you can use shortcodes like 'da' for a Devil's Advocate perspective, 'rt' for a Red Team adversarial attack, or 'gr' for an intense Gordon Ramsay-style review.

What is the 'meta-analysis' in the synthesis?

The meta-analysis is a final layer where Claude evaluates the critics themselves, identifying what was exaggerated and what represents a genuine, high-priority risk.

Brutal Review

Name: Brutal Review
Author: fiatkongen

byfiatkongen

0•

生产力与工作流

Provides high-intensity, multi-perspective critical analysis of business strategies and ideas to identify hidden flaws and risks.

Brutal Review is a specialized stress-testing skill designed to battle-test business plans, pitches, and strategies before they face real-world stakes. By deploying a trio of distinct personas—the inquisitive Devil's Advocate, the adversarial Red Team, and the uncompromising Gordon Ramsay—it delivers a comprehensive audit of your ideas. The skill goes beyond surface-level comments, using frameworks like Assumption Autopsies and Pre-Mortems to find 'kill shots' in your logic. It concludes with a synthesized meta-analysis that highlights high-confidence signals and actionable fixes, ensuring your strategy is hardened against failure.

主要功能

01Three-tier critical analysis with escalating intensity levels

020 GitHub stars

03Meta-analysis layer to filter theatricality and identify shared blind spots

04Support for targeted single-persona critiques via shortcodes (da, rt, gr)

05Automated synthesis that identifies consensus among different critics

06Persona-specific frameworks including Assumption Autopsy and Threat Mapping

使用场景

01Stress-testing a startup pitch or new business model before investor meetings

02Conducting a strategic pre-mortem to identify why a project might fail

03Reviewing marketing strategies or product launches for logical inconsistencies

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add fiatkongen/saurun-marketplace brutal-review

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT

Download Skill