When should the AI push back on a reviewer's suggestion?

Push back occurs if a suggestion breaks functionality, lacks full context, violates YAGNI principles, is technically incorrect for the stack, or conflicts with prior architectural decisions.

What is the recommended response pattern for reviews?

The pattern involves six steps: Read, Understand (restate), Verify against codebase, Evaluate technical soundness, Respond with technical acknowledgment, and Implement one tested item at a time.

How does it handle unclear feedback?

It mandates stopping the implementation process immediately and asking for clarification on all items to ensure a partial understanding doesn't lead to incorrect code.

Why does this skill prohibit saying 'You're right'?

The skill prohibits performative agreement to ensure the AI prioritizes technical correctness and codebase reality over social comfort or sycophancy.

Code Review Reception

Name: Code Review Reception
Author: yang0

byyang0

0•

协作工具

Establishes a rigorous technical protocol for processing code review feedback with verification and zero performative agreement.

This skill optimizes how Claude processes and implements code review feedback by prioritizing technical verification over social compliance. It provides a structured response pattern that mandates understanding requirements, verifying suggestions against the codebase, and evaluating technical soundness before any implementation occurs. By prohibiting performative phrases like 'You're absolutely right' and enforcing YAGNI checks, it ensures that code changes are driven by technical necessity and architectural integrity rather than blind adherence to reviewer suggestions.

主要功能

01Specific workflows for handling unclear or technically questionable feedback

02Technical verification protocol to prevent blind implementation

03Automated YAGNI checks for suggested unnecessary features

04Structured response pattern for processing multi-item feedback

050 GitHub stars

06Elimination of performative and sycophantic conversational language

使用场景

01Maintaining architectural integrity when faced with unnecessary feature requests

02Processing feedback from human partners or external technical reviewers

03Managing multi-item code reviews with varying levels of clarity

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add yang0/superpower receiving-code-review

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT

主要功能

01Specific workflows for handling unclear or technically questionable feedback

02Technical verification protocol to prevent blind implementation

03Automated YAGNI checks for suggested unnecessary features

04Structured response pattern for processing multi-item feedback

050 GitHub stars

06Elimination of performative and sycophantic conversational language

使用场景

01Maintaining architectural integrity when faced with unnecessary feature requests

02Processing feedback from human partners or external technical reviewers

03Managing multi-item code reviews with varying levels of clarity

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add yang0/superpower receiving-code-review

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT