Concept Critic

关于

Acts as a critical partner to apply rigorous intellectual scrutiny to concept designs before implementation. This skill uses a demanding methodology, inspired by Daniel Jackson, to validate a concept's structure, purpose, and operational principle against 8 essential criteria. It is designed to challenge assumptions, identify common design anti-patterns, and provide direct, unsugarcoated feedback to ensure a concept is sound, independent, and delivers genuine user value.

主要功能

• Critiques the operational principle for specificity, value, and logical soundness
• 0 GitHub stars
• Validates concepts against 8 essential criteria (e.g., User-Facing, Independent, End-to-End)
• Enforces a structured critique workflow to ensure all required elements are present
• Provides direct, unsugarcoated feedback to strengthen or redesign flawed concepts
• Identifies common design anti-patterns like multi-purpose concepts and hidden dependencies

使用场景

• Validate a new feature concept before committing to development
• Review and refine a product's core concepts during the initial design phase
• Challenge assumptions and identify weaknesses in an existing concept design