连接

Economic Research Reviewer Lens

brycewang-stanfordbybrycewang-stanford
•
1.1k
•
学习与文档

Performs comprehensive pre-submission audits for 《经济研究》 (Economic Research Journal) manuscripts against frequent structural reviewer criticisms.

Economic Research Reviewer Lens is a specialized pre-submission auditing skill tailored for academic authors submitting to top-tier economics journals, specifically 《经济研究》 (Economic Research Journal). It anticipates and systematically evaluates high-frequency, structural reviewer critiques across theoretical framing, identification strategies (such as staggered DiD and IV checks), mechanism verification, heterogeneity testing, and academic formatting. By providing a structured 10-question self-check and diagnostic output with severity ratings, it helps researchers identify fatal flaws, improve causal inference rigor, and refine manuscripts before peer review.

主要功能

01Audits causal identification strategies including staggered DiD, Bacon decomposition, and IV exogeneity
021,074 GitHub stars
03Evaluates theoretical contributions against journal-specific standards and recent literature
04Generates structured risk diagnostic reports with severity ratings and linked remediation skills
05Validates empirical mechanism designs according to standard Chinese economics literature benchmarks
06Provides a 10-point pre-submission stress test covering data, heterogeneity, and citations

使用场景

01Pre-submission self-auditing of finished economics manuscripts to preempt peer review rejections
02Collaborative peer review between co-authors using standardized journal-specific evaluation criteria
03Post-rejection root-cause analysis to systematically identify structural and technical weaknesses