JFM Referee Strategy & Report Triage
Anticipates market microstructure referee objections and triages review reports for Journal of Financial Markets submissions.
The JFM Referee Strategy skill prepares finance researchers for the rigorous peer review process of the Journal of Financial Markets (JFM). It conducts pre-submission pre-mortems to surface predictable specialist objections—such as liquidity measurement artifacts, endogeneity, and unclustered panel inference—allowing authors to address weaknesses before submission. Post-decision, it decodes editor signals, assesses whether requested revisions are tractable or indicate a near-reject, and categorizes referee comments into actionable triage buckets to streamline the rebuttal and revise-and-resubmit (R&R) workflow.
主要功能
01Assesses revision tractability and decodes editor decision letter priorities
02Pre-empts common liquidity measurement and identification challenges with concrete exhibits
03Conducts pre-submission pre-mortems targeting microstructure specialist critiques
04Identifies advocacy hooks like institutional precision and novel mechanisms to win referee support
05Triages referee comments into fatal-if-true, fixable, defensible, and editor-flagged categories
061,086 GitHub stars
使用场景
01Evaluating whether an editor's revision request is technically tractable or a hidden rejection
02Triaging a Journal of Financial Markets R&R report and extracting editor priorities
03Running a pre-submission pre-mortem on an empirical market microstructure paper