How does Claude handle disagreements with a reviewer?

The skill provides a framework for professional pushback using technical reasoning, such as identifying where a suggestion breaks existing functionality or violates architectural decisions.

Why does this skill forbid saying 'thanks' or 'excellent point'?

To prioritize technical action over performative social interaction. It ensures the focus remains on code correctness and saves time by communicating through implementation rather than gratitude.

How does this skill handle unclear feedback?

It implements a 'stop and ask' protocol. Claude will restate the requirements as understood and request clarification on ambiguous items before making any changes.

What is the 'YAGNI check' in this context?

When a reviewer suggests adding complex features, the skill greps the codebase to see if the functionality is actually used. If not, it suggests removing the requirement to avoid bloat.

Receiving Code Review

Name: Receiving Code Review
Author: tajohnson

bytajohnson

0•

协作工具

Evaluates and implements code review feedback using technical rigor rather than performative agreement to ensure codebase integrity.

This skill provides a structured framework for Claude to handle code review feedback with professional objectivity. It replaces social pleasantries and blind implementation with a disciplined verification pattern: Read, Understand, Verify, Evaluate, Respond, and Implement. By prioritizing technical correctness over social comfort, the skill ensures that suggestions are cross-referenced with the existing codebase, YAGNI principles are applied to 'professional' feature requests, and pushback is provided when feedback conflicts with established architectural decisions. It is particularly useful for teams using GitHub who want to ensure their AI assistant maintains high engineering standards while interacting with both trusted partners and external contributors.

主要功能

01Specific protocols for pushing back with technical reasoning

020 GitHub stars

03Automatic YAGNI checks for suggested feature expansions

04Structured 'Verify Before Implementing' response pattern

05Tiered verification for internal vs. external reviewer feedback

06Elimination of performative fillers like 'Great point' or 'You're right'

使用场景

01Processing batch feedback from senior engineers while maintaining technical rigor

02Clarifying ambiguous or contradictory review comments before writing code

03Vetting external contributions to ensure they don't break existing functionality

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add tajohnson/superpowers receiving-code-review

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT

主要功能

01Specific protocols for pushing back with technical reasoning

020 GitHub stars

03Automatic YAGNI checks for suggested feature expansions

04Structured 'Verify Before Implementing' response pattern

05Tiered verification for internal vs. external reviewer feedback

06Elimination of performative fillers like 'Great point' or 'You're right'

使用场景

01Processing batch feedback from senior engineers while maintaining technical rigor

02Clarifying ambiguous or contradictory review comments before writing code

03Vetting external contributions to ensure they don't break existing functionality